Craig Conover’s Rumored New Girlfriend Natalie Buffett: What We Know

   

Most Bravo fans were not expecting Craig Conover to go into  2025 a single man. For three years, he had been tied to Summer House’s Paige DeSorbo. But after buying an engagement ring, the influencer got cold feet. She ended their relationship shortly after Thanksgiving, leaving Craig allegedly blindsided. However, Craig didn’t let a little heartbreak get him down. He is now supposedly dating Natalie Buffett. Here’s what we know.  

When did Craig Conover and Paige DeSorbo break up?

Southern Charm fans had no idea that there was trouble in paradise. Even though the newest season of Summer House is showing their love at its breaking point, hindsight is always 20/20. Paige recently explained a bit more about the reason why she chose to end their relationship. During the Summer House After Show, she stated, “I think obviously when you’re in it, you can’t see it the way you see it when you’re out of it or the way your friends see it. I think I loved him so much that I tolerated too much. And now that I’m out of it and look back at things, I’m like ‘Oh, wait …’” 

The insight didn’t shock viewers who recently watched Craig tell Paige she would have to choose between work or children. After reflecting upon her relationship, she noted, “Any time that I had a career milestone, he found a way to make it about him. Or any time I had something for me like my friend’s wedding or a family wedding, he would make it about him. And make me have a bad time.”

Who is Craig Conover’s new girlfriend?

Whatever Paige is saying isn’t bothering Craig too much anymore, as he now has a new person to hold tight. For as long as fans have watched Craig, it has been evident that he wanted the fairytale ending for himself. And he just might have found it in Natalie. She is quite the beauty and currently works as a model and social media influencer. According to her Linkedin, she graduated from Southern Methodist University in Dallas with a degree in civil engineering in 2019. So, she has beauty and brains. Natalie is no stranger to dating in the public eye. Her roster before Craig is impressive. She dated Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott from 2020 to 2022. She then moved on to Jack Flaherty in 2024, who pitched for the Detroit Tigers. 

Craig spoke up about his dating life on Watch What Happens Live, saying he was “really happy” about his new girlfriend. He added, “When I date, I tend to date only one person at a time, so I’ve been seeing someone, and I have been reminded that the universe works in crazy ways, but everything happens for a reason.” 

Who is Natalie Buffett’s father?

The outlet Deuxmoi reported that Natalie was in the audience and seen at the airport with Craig later on. A source also told the outlet that Craig and Natalie had reportedly dated back in 2019. But a trip to the Bahamas veered them off course. The insider shared that “an argument ensued, and Natalie left Craig to spend time with other acquaintances in the area.” Supposedly, the pair have been exclusive for the last few months. With a last name like Buffett, it didn’t take long for fans to speculate that she could be related to financial mogul Warren Buffett or the singer Jimmy Buffett. So let’s get a little back story on the two men.

In the 1980s, the Margaritaville singer became friends with Warren and a shareholder in Berkshire Hathaway. They called each other “Cousin Jimmy” and “Uncle Warren,” but they are not related. Jimmy has three children – Savannah and Delaney and a son Cameron – none of whom are named Natalie. She is not the heir to the singer’s fortune. It is unclear who Natalie’s mother and father are at this time. However, we can say that there is absolutely no relation between Warren and Jimmy. While it is nice to see Craig moving on, I hope he doesn’t start calling Nat “chicken.”