Shep Rose Reveals Shocking Off-Camera Conversation with Sienna Evans: “Crazy...”

Want more exclusive Bravo merchandise? Explore must-haves from your favorite shows at ShopbyBravo.com.

If Southern Charm viewers were left scratching their heads over the relationship between Shep Rose and Sienna Evans,  they weren't the only ones.

On a new episode of the Southern Charm After Show, Shep revealed to Austen Kroll that he had reason to be surprised by his then-girlfriend's cool reception once the cast arrived in the Bahamas.

After an awkward conversation about their future together, and a dinner during which Sienna replied "I don't know" when Madison LeCroy asked if they were dating, Sienna told Shep she "had a stomachache" and went home, as seen on Season 10, Episode 11.

According to Shep, it wasn't always like that. Not even remotely.

Shep Rose reveals what Sienna Evans told him off-camera

"You know what's crazy?" he asked Austen during the Southern Charm After Show. "Two weeks earlier, she was like 'I can't wait for you to come down!' I was like 'Yeah, me too.'" 

Shep continued, "I asked, 'Are you staying with me?' and she said, 'Of course I'm staying with you! Where else would I stay?' What a difference two weeks makes."

Shep Rose and Sienna Evans having a conversation together during Southern Charm Season 10, Episode 11. Photo: Bravo

He also revealed that he tried to "smooch her, a little bit" to say goodnight when she left after dinner, and she turned him down. He got the sense then that that the relationship was done, but admitted he didn't know why. 

"It was confusing," Shep admitted, "But it was so clear at the same time."

Rodrigo Reyes reveals details of his vacation with Shep Rose and Sienna Evans

The other cast members also weighed in on Shep and Sienna's relationship during the Southern Charm After Show.

Rodrigo Reyes said to Taylor Ann Green that he thought Sienna's behavior at dinner was especially "weird" because he'd "spent time together" with Shep and Sienna as a couple already, along with Austen, Austen's girlfriend, Audrey Pratt, and Rodrigo's beau, Tyler Dugas.

"I mean, we'd gone to Hilton Head. Tyler, Audrey, Austen, Shep, we'd all hung out," he confirmed.

Rodrigo was confused because he and Tyler had loved Sienna and had so much fun with her before when they had seen her.

"Every experience I'd had was so lovely. There was like a definite switch was flipped," he explained. "She was very standoffish."