Despite seeing “little bits and pieces” of unfavorable reports about the rocker, Shay insisted that “he could not have been nicer.”
“We ended up at a different food truck in like a five to 10-minute conversation with some mutual friends,” she continued. “He’s from San Diego and we just talked about that.”
“Then I ran into them again later back at the hotel at the end of the night, and he was just such a sweet guy.”
Shay said she even “caught the end” of Martin’s set at the festival after leaving Fall Out Boy “a little early.”
Shay said “he could not have been nicer.” Getty Images
“He was just such a sweet guy,” she said of the guitarist. WireImage
“They were playing at the same time but I wanted to check out Sleeping with Sirens,” she explained. “I wanted to see what the band was all about and they were really good.”
Overall, the mother of one said it was a “fun” experience and she was thrilled to have met Maloney’s new man.
“I was glad I got to see her, meet him, see the band and overall it was a very fun weekend.”
Page Six confirmed the couple was dating last week. Getty Images
Maloney revealed she had a boyfriend on her podcast earlier this month — but didn’t reveal her beau’s identity. Getty Images
Last week, Page Six exclusively reported that Maloney was dating the 41-year-old musician after meeting through mutual friends in the music industry.
An insider told us the two “bonded” over their respective endeavors in hospitality as Maloney is the co-owner of the Something About Her sandwich shop while Martin runs a coffee company named Charlie Royal.
“Katie loves the emo music scene and has been a fan and friend of Nick’s band for some time,” the insider shared. “While the pair started out as friends, things took a turn this past summer in August and their relationship developed really quickly.”
Maloney called Martin the “most wonderful person [she’s] ever met.” Disrespectfully/YouTube
She admitted to being in love with the musician. Getty Images
Although the couple were “trying to keep things under wraps” due to Martin’s ongoing divorce, Maloney recently told fans about their relationship.
“So, I have a boyfriend,” she gushed during the most recent episode of her “Disrespectfully” podcast.
“Yeah, I’m in love, everybody. Katie’s in love! Yeah, I’m really happy.”
Although Maloney didn’t reveal his identity at the time, she described Martin as the “most wonderful person [she’s] ever met.”
Maloney’s last serious relationship was with Tom Schwartz, whom she divorced in 2022. Getty Images
“He just makes me feel really special, and he’s really special, and yeah, I’m just really, really happy,” she raved.
Maloney, shockingly, shared the big news on ex-husband Tom Schwartz’s birthday. The exes announced their divorce in 2022 after over a decade together.
Martin, for his part, wed his estranged wife, Jenna, in 2016. It’s unclear exactly when they split but we’re told the rocker isn’t letting their “heavy divorce” stop him from “growing his relationship with Katie in the meantime.”