May-December Rose Ceremony! Who Went Home on 'Bachelor in Paradise' 2025 Tonight?

May-December Rose Ceremony! Who Went Home on 'Bachelor in Paradise' 2025 Tonight? originally appeared on Parade.

After last week's two-parter that was full of drama, the Bachelor in Paradise stars got a much-needed breather this week. One new Golden was introduced, Gary Levingston, and the Rose Ceremony happened fairly early on in the episode.

The women had the power this week, though one woman did not wield her power very well because she did not heed the massive red flags being waved in front of her face. And two new ladies arrived at the resort!

Below are all the details on who went home, who stayed and who coupled up, but be warned of spoilers ahead. Don't keep reading if you don't want to be spoiled.

Who went home on the Bachelor in Paradise Season 10, episode 4 in 2025 tonight?

In a fun twist, April Kirkwood hadn't really hit it off with someone to the point where she really wanted to give them a rose, so she offered her rose to Jonathon Johnson because she adores him so much and wanted him to get another chance, so Jonathon did not have to go home this week.

The three men who were sent home were:

Charles “CK” King

Jack Lencioni

Ralph “RJ” Johnson

RELATED: 'Bachelor in Paradise' Star Breaks Down That 'Insane' Rose Ceremony

What was the Dale Moss and Kat Izzo drama?

Right before the Rose Ceremony, Dale Moss showed his true colors with Kat Izzo when she wanted to hash things out about him kissing Alli Jo Hinkes last week and not telling her until she pointedly asked him (earlier in the episode). He was incredibly dismissive of her feelings, and that was definitely not a smart way to play that (or very nice or thoughtful).

He also won't stop saying a completely made-up word that means nothing, telling Kat he "deaded it" with Alli Jo. She, like the rest of us, is like, "Stop trying to make 'deaded it' happen, Dale."

When Dale finally got tired of having to listen to Kat's (totally legitimate) feelings, he exasperatedly told her she was sounding a lot like his ex. Hmmm. Maybe somebody needs to introduce Dale to this gif. After all that, he said in a talking head interview, "She should just move on and gimme a rose." He also can't stop complaining and moaning about her to anyone who will listen, and he actually says to Kat that they should've waited to talk about it until tomorrow. Um, dude. Stop.

He was just mad because she had the rose, and he knew he might go home. If the roles were reversed, he would have flipped out, and we all know it.

Unfortunately, Kat did not take note of these massive red flags and gave her rose to Dale. In fact, right after he got her rose, he was still being a total child about everything. Red flag, Kat! Red Flag! RUN!

Who are the remaining couples on Bachelor in Paradise Season 10 in 2025?

Spencer and Jess

Dale and Kat

Jeremy and Bailey

Brian and Parisa

Natascha and Gary

Leslie and Kim

Kathy and Keith

Jill and Sean

April and Jonathon

🌹 SIGN UP for our The Bachelor newsletter to stay up to date on the latest Bachelor Nation news, exclusive interviews, episode recaps & more 🌹

Who is left on Bachelor in Paradise Season 10 in 2025?

The three new ladies who arrived were Lea Cayanan (young), Nancy Hulkower (Golden) and Faith Martin (Golden). It did not escape the Golden ladies' attention that with April giving her rose to Jonathon, that left fewer Golden men to give out roses to the Golden women. There are only three GMs left compared to now six GWs. Also, Nancy and Faith are "smokin' hot," according to the Golden men, so the Golden women who were already there were not super jazzed about that.

Alexe Godin

28, Pediatric speech therapist, New Brunswick, Canada
Grant Ellis’ Bachelor season 29

Andrew Spencer

30, former pro football player, Lake Villa, IL
Katie Thurston's Bachelorette se

April Kirkwood

67, Therapist, Port St. Lucie, FL
Gerry Turner’s Golden Bachelor season 1

Bailey Brown

28, Social media manager, Atlanta, GA
Grant Ellis’ Bachelor season 29

Brian Autz

34, Aesthetics consultant, Boynton Beach, FL
Jenn Tran’s Bachelorette season 21

Dale Moss

36, Former NFL wide receiver, Brandon, SD
Clare Crawley’s Bachelorette season 16

Faith Martin

61, Benton City, WA
High school teacher

Gary Levingston

66, Retired finance executive, Palm Desert, CA
Joan Vassos’ Golden Bachelorette season 1

Jeremy Simon

31, Real estate investor, New York
Jenn Tran’s Bachelorette season 21

Jess Edwards

26, Executive assistant, San Diego, CA
Joey Graziadei’s Bachelor season 28

Jill Chin

30, architectural historian, Scituate, RI
Clayton Echard's Bachelor season 26 and Bachelor in Paradise season 8

Jonathon Johnson

28, Creative director, Los Angeles
Jenn Trann’s Bachelorette season 21

Kat Izzo

29, Registered nurse, Tampa, FL
Zach Shallcross’ Bachelor season 27 and Bachelor in Paradise season 9

Kathy Swarts

72, Retired educational consultant, Austin, TX
Gerry Turner’s Golden Bachelor season 1

Keith Gordon

63, Girl dad, Columbus, IN
Joan Vassos’ Golden Bachelorette season 1

Kim Buike

70, Retired Navy captain, Seattle
Joan Vassos’ Golden Bachelorette season 1

Lea Cayanan

24, Account manager, Waipahu, HI
Joey Graziadei’s Bachelor season 28

Leslie Fhima

66, Fitness instructor, Golden Valley, MN
Gerry Turner’s Golden Bachelor season 1

Natascha Hardee

62, Pro-aging coach and speaker, New York
Gerry Turner’s Golden Bachelor season 1

Nancy Hulkower

62, Alexandria, VA
Retired interior designer

Parisa Shifteh

30, pediatric behavior analyst, Birmingham, MI
Grant Ellis’ Bachelor season 29

Sean McLaughlin

27, Software sales rep, Troy, NY
Charity Lawson’s Bachelorette season 20 and Bachelor in Paradise season 9

Spencer Conley

32, Pet portrait entrepreneur, Dallas, TX
Jenn Tran’s Bachelorette season 21

Additionally, though not introduced yet, there are two more younger contestants who were revealed in a trailer for the show who haven't arrived yet:

Allyshia Gupta

29, Interior designer, Wesley Chapel, FL
Grant Ellis’ Bachelor season 29

Bachelor in Paradise airs Monday nights at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC.

May-December Rose Ceremony! Who Went Home on 'Bachelor in Paradise' 2025 Tonight? first appeared on Parade on Jul 22, 2025