Patrick Mahomes’ Madden NFL 26 rating has ignited widespread frustration among Kansas City Chiefs fans, who view the quarterback’s drop to a 95 overall as a glaring oversight. Known for his consistency and postseason dominance, Mahomes finds himself ranked behind Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, and Joe Burrow, sparking debates over the fairness of EA Sports’ evaluations.
Mahomes led Kansas City to its third consecutive Super Bowl appearance in 2024, cementing his status as one of the league’s premier talents. Despite his accomplishments, including two NFL MVP awards and three Super Bowl victories, the Madden rankings have seemingly prioritized short-term performances over sustained excellence. Fans argue that Mahomes’ legendary playoff runs and leadership deserve better recognition.
The controversy extends beyond Mahomes, as no Chiefs player made the “99 Club” in Madden 26. Defensive tackle Chris Jones, pivotal to Kansas City’s defensive success, also missed the mark with a 97 rating. Meanwhile, center Creed Humphrey earned a 95 overall, solidifying his status as the NFL’s top-rated center, yet the team’s collective exclusion from elite honors has left fans questioning EA’s criteria.
Travis Kelce, another cornerstone of Kansas City’s success, experienced a significant drop to a 93 overall rating. Despite his age, Kelce’s postseason contributions and game-changing ability remain unrivaled. Fans view these ratings as a broader narrative shift that underestimates Kansas City’s dominance and undervalues its key players.
NFL fans have shared their thoughts about Mahomes and other Chiefs players’ Madden rating. These reactions can be seen in a post shared by Kansas City’s official Instagram account.
“Mahomes disrespect,” a fan said. “It should be against the law to have Mahomes only 95 overall,” another added.
A supporter mentioned, “the kelce disrespect is even crazier.”
“Why isn’t Mcduffie a 99??” a follower asked.
“No Trey Smith is disrespectful tbh,” a commenter posted.
“95 is crazy bro is the best QB IN THE HISTORY OF THE NFL DISGUSTING,” a sixth social media user reacted.
Criticism of the Madden 26 ratings highlights the tension between statistical algorithms and the intangible qualities that define elite players. Mahomes and his teammates have built their reputations on proving doubters wrong, and this perceived disrespect could fuel their on-field performances in the upcoming season.
Ultimately, the debate underscores the passion of Kansas City fans and the high expectations for their stars. As Mahomes and company prepare for another championship run, their Madden ratings may only add fuel to their pursuit of greatness.
