If the New York Giants are serious about drafting a quarterback this offseason, bolstering their offensive line has to be a top priority. Ranked 28th in the NFL in pass protection last season, the Giants struggled mightily to give their quarterbacks time to operate. While injuries and inconsistency played a significant role, the team needs to address its lack of high-end talent and depth, particularly at offensive guard. Enter Kansas City Chiefs standout Trey Smith, a player who could be the solution to many of their problems.
Trey Smith: An Anchor in the Trenches
Trey Smith has developed into one of the NFL’s premier interior linemen, and he’s coming off his best season yet. The former sixth-round pick in 2021 slipped in the draft due to concerns over a blood clot, but he has more than silenced those doubts with his performance.
Over 1129 snaps in 2024, Smith allowed just 27 pressures and, remarkably, zero sacks. His penalty count was a bit high at nine, but his 78.8 PFF grade marked a career-best, highlighting his growth and consistency.
Smith’s combination of size, power, and athleticism makes him a nightmare for opposing defensive linemen. He’s equally adept at handling pass rushers and opening lanes in the running game, making him an all-around force on the offensive line. If the Giants were to invest in Smith, they’d be getting a player who could solidify the right side of their line for years to come.
Price Tag: A Worthwhile Investment
Smith will undoubtedly be one of the most sought-after offensive linemen in free agency, and his price tag is expected to reflect that. The 24-year-old could command around $20 million annually, a steep price but one that could be justified if the Giants find themselves with a quarterback on a rookie deal. Protecting that young passer should be priority number one, and Smith would go a long way in achieving that goal.
While Smith’s cost may seem daunting, the Giants could make it work financially by moving on from aging veterans and reallocating resources toward their offensive line. With a young quarterback likely stepping into the fold, it makes sense to invest heavily in the trenches to ensure his development isn’t derailed by poor protection.
Depth Options: Van Roten and Beyond
While Smith represents the top-tier solution, the Giants also have to consider their depth, which was tested severely in 2024. Greg Van Roten, who filled in admirably at guard, is a candidate to return. The 34-year-old allowed 35 pressures and seven sacks last season, which isn’t stellar, but he was serviceable considering he was making near the league minimum. He’s better suited as a backup, offering insurance in case of injuries.
The problem with relying on players like Van Roten is the lack of upside. The Giants need a true difference-maker to elevate their offensive line from mediocre to formidable. Trey Smith fits that mold perfectly, but the team must also ensure they have capable backups to avoid another collapse if injuries strike again.
Smith: The Key to a Rookie Quarterback’s Success
If the Giants draft a quarterback, protecting him has to be non-negotiable. Trey Smith’s blend of youth, talent, and consistency makes him an ideal target for a team desperate for stability along the offensive line. Having a line that includes Smith, Andrew Thomas, Jermaine Eluemunor, and Jon Runyan would be exciting.
Smith represents more than just a guard; he’s an anchor, a player who can be the bedrock of a rebuilt offensive line. For the Giants, the question isn’t whether they should pursue Smith but whether they can afford not to.
