Kicking is often an afterthought in the NFL, but this phase of the game can determine outcomes of division titles, playoff contests, and even Super Bowls. The Green Bay Packers enjoyed years of stability at the position thanks to Mason Crosby, but is he the greatest kicker in franchise history?
The best kickers are the ones you don't talk about. Much like a movie editor, people only bring up your name if you make a mistake. If fans are actually watching an extra-point attempt, chances are, the kicker is under pressure.
It's also one of the most unforgiving positions in all of sports. Even the most reliable and consistent kickers can find themselves out of work after a string of bad performances. It's that important.
Who are the greatest kickers in Packers history? That's what we are here to find out.
Criteria for selection
Consistency and handling pressure. If you can't check both of those boxes, you likely won't last long as an NFL kicker. It's crucial to provide stability at the position, making kicks within 40 yards look easy while also converting a healthy percentage of longer kicks.
The best of the best can do it when the whole world is watching. Whether it's a game-winner in the regular season or a kick in key moments of a playoff game, the kickers who can get the job done under immense pressure deserve extra credit.
Longevity is also a factor. It's hard to make kicks consistently, year in and year out. Every kicker goes through challenging stretches in their career, but the best can overcome that and regain their composure.
What about moments? Crucial kicks when the season was on the line? Kicking in the NFL is mostly a thankless job, but they can create moments that live forever.
